Derpibooru - Oc Unguligrade Anthro Nudity Looking Back Balls -gif -changeling -bat -penis
Archonix
Retired Ass
@saby
She has rubies embedded in her eyeballs and she's crying blood.
e: and yes, I know what twinkle ponies are, in case you mention it. This is obviously meant to be a horror twist on their origin story.
saby
Assistant
fun at parties
@Archonix
But unless you know the artists' intention, there's no way to distinguish from a normal twinkle-eyed pony crying a dark liquid. And even if the gore factor's evident enough, shouldn't the picture be tagged per gore, not horror?
Not trying to be a crank, this issue perplexes me.
Posted Report
Archonix
Retired Ass
@saby
A de-cartoonified origin story for the twinkle ponies is that they had crystals embedded in their eyes while working as mine slaves. Add her crying "a dark liquid" to that, blood and scarring around the crystals on her eyeballs, her general expression, the description implying blindness, and the overall dark scheme of the image, and you pretty much get a poster for a horror movie.
On top of which, it's rated mature at the source.
Princess Luna
Senior Moderator
Site Developer
Tag Czar
@Rainboom Dash
I think it should generally be Questionable. Grinding is a bit of an odd case for ratings in general because it's non-visible possible genital stimulation.
@saby
If you look closely at the eyes, there's details that make it look like they're rather injured, not just unusual in the shape of the pupils, so I think Semi-grimdark is correct here.
Posted Report
Background Pony #4230
Is this indeed safe, not suggestive?
>>2374503
Posted Report
Princess Luna
Senior Moderator
Site Developer
Tag Czar
Posted Report
saby
Assistant
fun at parties
@Background Pony #4230
And the "hands-free milkshake challenge" pose/action exists to put focus on breasts.
Posted Report
saby
Assistant
fun at parties
Here to confirm that this picture should be "suggestive", not "safe".
Posted Report
Background Pony #91Z0
Wait if "sex" is explicit but "sex" (gender) is safe, why is same sex safe?
Princess Luna
Senior Moderator
Site Developer
Tag Czar
@Background Pony #91Z0
I think you're very confused about different meanings of a word.
Posted Report
saby
Assistant
fun at parties
@Background Pony #91Z0
You write "same sex" but link "safe sex".
Words have different meanings in different contexts. "Safe" in the phrase "safe sex" means that the sex is practised with precautions to prevent unwanted pregnancies, transmittance of STIs, etc. "Safe" in the context of the rating tag here on Derpibooru means the picture has no such content that wouldn't be okay to show to children.
There are many more seeming contradictions. The same image can be tagged "good clean married sex" (it's "good and clean" because it's between married partners) and "filthy dirty married sex" (it's "filthy and dirty" because it's kinky, but it also happens to be between married partners).
Posted Report
Blissful690
Glimmy is best pony
@Background Pony #91Z0
"Safe" in the context of the rating tag here on Derpibooru means the picture has no such content that wouldn't be okay to show to children.
And there's been a longstanding problem with this site where there's been tons of images rated safe that aren't okay to show to children, such as ones containing swearing, drugs, and so forth.
Posted Report
saby
Assistant
fun at parties
Safe? And if the butt focus isn't enough for a "suggestive", should "ass" and "butt" be tagged? (Why do we have those two as separate tags anyways…)
Princess Luna
Senior Moderator
Site Developer
Tag Czar
@saby
I think so. Ass is for butts that are on more human-like creatures. It's probably good to tag here, though it is a bit tenuous being that there's barely any hint of a crack.
Posted Report
Background Pony #B065
Uploaded as Suggestive, then changed to Questionable. Which is more appropriate?
Posted Report
Princess Luna
Senior Moderator
Site Developer
Tag Czar
@Background Pony #B065
Bit of a tricky one, but I think it's fine at Suggestive, since there's not much detail about what her hand is actually doing.
Posted Report
Rainboom Dash
Rainbooms4Ever
I changed this to safe as I don't really see anything suggestive about it >>2475315
Posted Report
Posted Report
Panko Pai
Shy gamer stallion
>>2492422 (NSFW)
Should the rating be kept Questionable or be re-rated to Explicit?
Twi's crotch is shown, but I can't see if her vulva is visible
Posted Report
Princess Luna
Senior Moderator
Site Developer
Tag Czar
@Panko Pai
I don't think there's any sign of a vulva there.
Posted Report
Yoshimon1
yay(){ yay|yay & };yay
There's some discussion in the comments about the rating of this picture because there's some very low-detail balls visible. It went from safe to suggestive to explicit now. IMO this should be suggestive at most.
(Also, not sure if this actually needs those (casual) nudity tags, but I guess they kinda apply.)
Posted Report
saby
Assistant
fun at parties
@Yoshimon1
Agree with "suggestive" at most.
balls, suggestive precedents
We also have a whole bunch of similar low focus low detail sheaths tagged as "safe", including original G1 show footage.
If any hint of recognisable testes is ruled to be non-safe, one of my own pieces will also be affected (there's also a similarly presented ponut):
Posted Report
Princess Luna
Senior Moderator
Site Developer
Tag Czar
@Yoshimon1
Not sure on it overall, but Explicit is odd for a partial outline, and Suggestive makes more sense.
@saby
Most of that is references or clothing outlines (many of which even look like they need rerating). >>603011 and >>10417 are the only clear cases of actual balls being Suggestive-rated at the moment, and >>1718613 is arguable. Definitely not much as far as precedent; you'll find a lot more looking at Questionable, which has the most comparable image:
Sheaths and especially anuses might get similar theoretical treatment, but they aren't a good point of comparison because their very nature is mild (close to the body and simple in shape). For >>1612273, it doesn't even quite qualify for the "anus" tag because it can't be clearly seen to be distinct from the fur on both sides.
Posted Report
Posted Report
Panko Pai
Shy gamer stallion
Posted Report
Derpibooru - Oc Unguligrade Anthro Nudity Looking Back Balls -gif -changeling -bat -penis
Source: https://derpibooru.org/forums/tagging/topics/rating-tags-general?post_id=4972898
0 Response to "Derpibooru - Oc Unguligrade Anthro Nudity Looking Back Balls -gif -changeling -bat -penis"
Post a Comment